Banca de DEFESA: Isaura Cristina de Oliveira Leite

Uma banca de DEFESA de MESTRADO foi cadastrada pelo programa.
STUDENT : Isaura Cristina de Oliveira Leite
DATE: 26/08/2022
TIME: 15:00
LOCAL: https://teams.microsoft.com/l/meetup-join/19%3a6afc08a0c0da4045966406f00a11 3d74%40thread.tacv2/1660
TITLE:

"The audiences and the discourse of the (Brazilian) Supreme Court: the effects of the virtualization of the judgements on the court's rhetoric."

KEY WORDS:

Rhetoric; Law; Virtual Plenary; Supreme Federal Court; Empirical-Rhetorical Discourse Analysis.

PAGES: 147
BIG AREA: Ciências Sociais Aplicadas
AREA: Direito
SUMMARY:

From the edition of Regimental Amendment 53, of March 18, 2020, which amended the Internal Regulations of the Supreme Federal Court (STF), all judgments within its competence can now be carried out before the so-called virtual plenary, an electronic judgment platform in which the ministers post their written votes, related to each process, without need of synchronous meeting to hold oral debates. At a time when more than ninety percent of court judgments began to take place on the virtual platform, the present work proposes to observe the consequences of this migration – from the physical to the virtual plenary – from the perspective of a rhetorical theory of law, which takes it as a rhetorically constructed social enterprise and foregrounds the discourse produced by the actors who manipulate it. For that, it was tried to produce a comparative analysis between the discourses coming from the physical and virtual plenary, seeking to detect and understand the differences and similarities of the rhetorical strategies used by the ministers in both environments. After carrying out a study about the characteristics of the virtual plenary and its judgment methodology, exposing the points that make it significantly different from the physical plenary, the research used the methodological instrument called Empirical-Rhetorical Analysis of Discourse to proceed with the rhetorical analysis of two judgments of the plenary of the STF, one coming from the physical environment and the other from the virtual environment. The resulting analysis revealed a significant difference in the quantity and classification of rhetorical markers constructed as parameters of analysis, revealing the eminently rhetorical character of judicial practice, given its sensitivity to changes in the institutional design of the trial environment in which its participants are immersed, alterations able of affecting the communicational relationship formed between the judges and their audience.

BANKING MEMBERS:
Presidente - 2132953 - ISAAC COSTA REIS
Interno - 2332291 - ALEXANDRE ARAUJO COSTA
Interno - 2095583 - NEY DE BARROS BELLO FILHO
Externo à Instituição - CARLOS MAGNO SPRICIGO VENERIO - UFF